×

When Jesus stood before Pilate, their conversation revealed a dilemma (John 18:28-40). Pilate knew that the accusations against Jesus were weak. He recognised his innocence, yet pressure from the crowd, the religious leaders, political concerns, and his wife’s warning left him conflicted and confused.  Pilate found himself caught between justice and fear.

Confronted by Jesus’s calm presence and his testimony about truth, he wrestled with questions far greater than the trial itself and asked, “What is truth?” (John 18:38).

“What is truth?” is not only the question of a ruler like Pilate under pressure; it is the question within each of our hearts. Today, we are surrounded by information, false narratives, loud voices, data, and opinions that confuse, challenge, and create fear within us. Like Pilate, whenever fear becomes louder than faith, whenever comfort appears safer than obedience, and whenever the approval of people feels more urgent than the approval of God, we ask this question in our hearts.

For Pilate, his world was shaped by empire, pressure, and public opinion, but our hearts have a similar struggle. The world and culture tell us that truth should be something we negotiate, edit, or avoid, based on context, opinions, and feelings.

The Transmission of Truth

Throughout history, human beings have struggled to communicate and hold on to the truth. In oral cultures, truth was remembered, recited, and repeated through generations, guarded within the community. Yet there was always the possibility that the truth could be diluted as generations passed, forgotten, or manipulated to fit the dominant narratives that leaders wanted to communicate. We see this throughout history, and even in the Bible, throughout the life of the nation of Israel.

Later, when handwritten manuscripts became the mode of communication, truth passed through faithful hands and careful interpretation. But then, as multiple, varied, and spurious copies emerged, narratives changed, interpretations diverged, and the truth became diluted and contested. The need for Christian creeds emerged out of such confusing and challenging interpretations.

With print media, truth appeared more permanent. But alongside print media that communicated truth, there was always yellow journalism, promoting and publishing alternatives to the truth.

The Digital Age

With radio, television, and film, truth became vivid, persuasive, and emotionally near. As commerce and the economy began to shape visual media, truth often became what attracted the largest audience. What the majority liked began to feel like the truth.

With social media, truth became immediate, personal, contested, and surrounded by an explosion of information and truth claims. Everyone now had access to platforms where they could promote what they felt was right and true. More than logic and reality, feelings, perceptions, and presumptions began to shape truth. Truth increasingly became what each person felt. This has been described by some as the digital orality era, returning in certain ways to aspects of earlier oral cultures.

The digital age has returned us to a kind of orality, but often without the shared conversations around the table, the embodied teacher, or the accountable community that once shaped listening. COVID was an interesting study in digital orality and truth. Everyone seemed to carry a claim—truth as each person perceived it. And even science and medicine, which were expected to be evidence-based, were affected. Everyone was an expert, and everyone seemed to have evidence-based arguments.

AI and Computational Truth

Artificial intelligence deepens this struggle because AI can make answers appear complete, efficient, and objective. It gathers data beyond our memory, detects patterns beyond our attention, and speaks with polished confidence.

But the AI engines available now are still based on what humans have placed into databases and digital spaces. The difference is that AI engines and Large Language Models (LLMs) can quickly scan through what humans have left behind, identify key concepts, and present them to us as truth within seconds. But with Artificial General Intelligence (AGI) potentially disrupting the AI revolution in the near future, will AI engines go beyond existing data and create truth from what they perceive as true and right? This remains unknown, but it is a possibility in the near future.

Data may describe behaviour, summarise consensus, and predict outcomes, but it is not embodied truth. A machine may process words, but it cannot become flesh and blood.

Data-Driven Versus Embodied Truth

This brings us back to Pilate and to our own hearts. Pilate had his own kind of data: political intelligence, legal authority, past experiences, public pressure, religious accusation, and private anxiety. But the question before him was not finally informational. It was spiritual. Truth was not hidden in a distant archive or buried beneath insufficient evidence. Truth stood before him in Jesus Christ. Pilate asked, “What is truth?” while looking into the face of the One who is the Way, the Truth, and the Life (John 14:6).

The danger for us is the same. We may gather information yet fail to recognise the one and only truth, Jesus (John 5:39-40). The Christian understanding is not only that Jesus teaches, models, or reveals truth among many competing truths. We confess that Jesus is the only Truth: the living, personal, eternal truth of God (John 1:14). The embodied truth who, through his life, death, and resurrection, sets us free from our bondage to sin and deception (John 8:32).

It is that truth living in our hearts that enables us to understand, “what is truth.”

Therefore, truth is not owned by institutions, manufactured by crowds, optimised by machines, or secured by power. Truth is received from Jesus, recognised through Jesus, and embodied in Jesus (John 17:17; 18:37). Those who follow him are called to become personifications of truth—not because we possess truth as a weapon, but because Jesus, the truth, has possessed and transformed us (Eph. 4:25).

Our words become truthful because they are surrendered to his Word. Our lives become truthful because they are conformed to his life. In a world of edited realities, shifting narratives, and confident illusions, our lives should not merely raise the question, “What is truth?” but communicate the truth found in Jesus.

LOAD MORE
Loading